I started a conversation then forgot about it.
I always thought Deep Space 9 was the best Trek show ever, and I'm old enough to remember the original series, and yes, I recognized your avatar, though don't ask me his name, as the memory stinks the older you get.
Of course, as good as DS9 was, Babylon 5 was still my favorite Sci-Fi show back in the day.
Ronald D. Moore was my favorite Trek writer, so Babylon 5 is on my list of shows to watch.
(His name is Garak, just plain, simple Garak--or Elim Garak, as we later learn.
)
OH I'd agree... DS9 was the BEST... well... but I did enjoy Voyager too... then again, I loved Picard in Next Gen... and I actually just bought and sat through the entire ENTERPRISE and actually enjoyed it... tho I won't re-watch those DVDs...
I'm well into NUMB3RS now and loving it... it's so different!
I loved Picard and Data; I liked Riker when he wasn't being a total misogynist jerk. But I found Geordi a little boring (he had his moments, but most of the time...), Crusher just exuded incompetence (not the fault of the actress, personally--just a dull character), Pulaski was a mild improvement but only lasted a season, and Troi--let us not speak of that abomination.
Scott Bakula is one of my favorite actors, so I loved Enterprise. I had a hard time getting into Voyager. It took me a very long time to warm up to Janeway. I'm not sure I ever really did fully warm up to her.
Funny how as I got older, I had more and more problems with Captain Kirk.
I think it's likely that Deep Space Nine is my favorite, followed by Enterprise. While I also think highly of Patrick Stewart, I just didn't care for the Borg storylines. I'm not sure whether I ever saw the entire series. I stopped watching TV during its run. It was quite a few years before I started watching "tv" again, not until online streaming hit the scene.
I hated Voyager. I really liked Janeway (let me rephrase: I really liked Kate Mulgrew), but the writing was inconsistent at best and there wasn't a single other likable character. I really
wanted to like Chakotay, but he was a giant walking stereotype. Tuvok was abominable (most emotional Vulcan
ever). I wanted to shove Paris out an airlock. The half-Klingon engineer (forget her name) was just angry. My only real memory of the Doctor was his DS9 appearance, where I also wanted to shove
him out an airlock (don't mess with my favorite character
). And then there's Ensign Forgettable; the "Korean" guy played by a Malaysian actor. Oh, and the alien--the feeble attempt to merge Quark and Guinan into a single character and failing.
There's also the fact that it asks me to sympathize with the Maquis, and after DS9 that's something I simply cannot do.
My issue with TNG is, at its heart, Roddenberry. With no disrespect intended towards a man who created such a wonderful franchise, Roddenberry did not understand good storytelling. He wanted to show this perfect, happy, sunny future of humanity in which all threats come from outside; frankly, that's incredibly boring. The most typical Roddenberry episode I can think of is the episode in which, immediately after being told his mother died, a very small child calmly says, "Thank you for telling me, captain. May I go back to my lesson now?"
Roddenberry was so obsessed with showing this perfect humanity, it makes most of early TNG
really boring. There are more human episodes later on (after Roddenberry's death), but it was too little, too late. What I love most about DS9 (aside from the characters and the writing) is the way it undermines that "perfect" future: one of my favorite moments in DS9 is Sisko's monologue in the two-part episode "Maquis," where he says that "it's easy to be a saint in paradise." (You can check out that speech
here; mild profanity warning.) DS9's characters were much more flawed and therefore much more human. I also appreciate that DS9 approaches religion with much more respect than other Trek franchises; as a religious person, TNG's hardcore atheism is at times a trifle abrasive.
I think the Borg were great in "Q Who?" and "The Best of Both Worlds," but they went seriously downhill after that. You can only defeat an "all-powerful" enemy so many times before it starts to look bad. "Descent" is the worst, and it doesn't help that I already don't like Lore.
Still, despite all of that, I have to admit my single favorite episode
is from TNG: "The Inner Light" is just a masterpiece of storytelling.