quietrob
Extraordinary
When doing dark scenes I am very conscious that others may not see the render just as I do. As you point out the surrounding light has a major impact as does the calibration of the monitor. My monitor is calibrated so that I get the colours I want when I send my renders for print so that may have a further impact. In this particular case I was trying, to a large degree, to keep the figure almost hidden as you can see if you compare my before and after shots. The result is really down to the fact that I intended to use it in a book, if that had not have been the case it would be very different.
Please don't see any of this as a defense to anything that has been said here, I do not feel under attack and I am always interested in how others view what I create. The whole idea of trying to create this book is directly due to suggestions and ideas made here. I am immensely grateful to anyone taking and interest in my art and the fact that they may see ways to make it better is a plus in my book as they are still showing interest.
If anyone likes any of my renders here then part of the credit for that has to go to all the people here who have helped, advise and guided me. I am so lucky to have found such and great and friendly bunch of artists and a home for my pictures.
Thank you again. No way am I trying to attack you. If it ever feels like that, I apologize. Perhaps it's a failing but I do care what others think about my work (unlike some who say they don't care what other's think). It's a good guidestone. Of course we're still going to pursue things from our points of view. We have to do. There is always the fact that one person, the artist, could be one hundred percent right in their vision and all others wrong. Yet by listening to those I respect, it allows me to think in a different way. Sometimes I take their advice, sometimes I don't but I listen. Hopefully I learn.